Recently, reports on the torture techniques of the Central Intelligence Angency were brought to light. People who were incarcerated without due process have been waterboarded, beaten, frozen, and kept wake for days on end. But it is not only the mere brutality of the methods that presents a problem, but also the fact that those being detained have not been have not been granted the legal rights garunteed to them by the constitution. This is a clear violation of liberty, property, and security. While the argument can certainly be made that most other branches of the government were mislead concerning the going-ons at Guantánamo Bay and other such detention facilities, it must be remembered that it is the government's responsibility to maintain proper oversight, transparency, and accountability. Given that the CIA is a government organization and that other branches failed to prevent this unlawful and unconstitutional violation of rights (whether or not this was due to misinformation is irrelevant), the government is directly ignoring the ideals of the Enlightenment which founded it. Yet the inhumane treatment of prisoners by the CIA is not the only way in which the government has failed to acknowledge these rights. The protests against police brutality sparked by the deaths of Mochael Brown and Eric Gardner have been met with, shockingly, police brutality. While some of the protests in which the police used violence were little more than thinly veiled excuses for looting, others were merely demonstrations of citizen's displeasure with the status quo. When demonstrating against police brutality is met with force, the right to resist oppression is no longer taken into account.
While the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen may not directly apply to the U.S., these rights should, looking at the issue from an idealistic standpoint rather than a realistic one, be universally maintained. In theory, these problems could be solved through more strict oversight, enforced regulation, and increased transparency and accountability for both the police and the CIA. While these were not necessarily guaranteed in the documents composed by revolutionaries, they were implied. For in order for these rights to be maintained, there must be a certain degree of regulation and accountability.
No comments:
Post a Comment